I went and read (actually read) Eol's whole wiki entry, among others, mostly to see what clan of elves he belonged to, and I was pleased to see that there are many versions, including a totally wild one where he is a Noldo born in Aman, but an "Avar at heart", and joins Feanor's host. See? My silly AU is backed by Tolkien himself!
Apparently Eol M has become a staple of my writing rn. I mean, he is basically just a declination of the tsundere archetype: cranky, foul mouthed, petty, with a penchant for violence under the wrong circumstances and a soft heart under the right ones + bonus competence! It pains me a little that, with Miriel and Sons around, I can't really have Feanor H as in the silly AU, but he's there in spirit. Mostly because I do believe Feanor and Eol are fundamentally the same (even if they would have been at odds, had they met).
Doriath keeps being a clusterfuck. Why didn't Melian girdle Nan Elmoth too? It's literally where she and her dumb husband met.
"He was "restless and ill at ease in
Doriath",
[4] and when the
Girdle of Melian was raised around the kingdom, he left his dwelling in the
Forest of Region to dwell in the dark forest of
Nan Elmoth, east of Doriath" Of course the whole spiel here is that Eol was bad etc. etc., but this quote, coupled with the one about the Green elves "guest-elves" who sort of hated being in Doriath too, and the bit about Doriathrin being the true and pure version of Sindarin, makes me think it wasn't such this amazing, welcoming place to be in.
It also backs up my idea that, had Eol been alive, Thingol would probably not have wanted him back in Doriath during the Dagor Bragollach and/or Eol would have chosen to go elsewhere (maybe south with Amras, Amrod and Caranthir).
"Anglachel he gave to Thingol as a begrudged payment for dwelling in Nan Elmoth"
Begrudging, see? [Edit: didn't Feanor "gudge" the sight of the Silmarils to everybody but his father and sons???
SEE???]
"Height: Tall, but stooped by smithwork" What? LOL
"Hair-colour: Dark-haired" Nah
Also, where is Anguirel? I'd never considered that!
I wanted to write this post two hours ago but I ended up reading a couple of fics by SpaceWall, whom I vaguely remember from back when I was in fandom.
The fics weren't bad, I have to be honest - as far as "mainstream" Silm fic goes. Especially that one where Elrond is angry at his not-mom and then he goes to see Fingon and there's Maedhros too. The Fingon/Maedhros still rubs me all the possible wrong ways, but the fic was overall really nice. Repentant Feanor also still rubs me wrong, very very wrong.
Mostly I'm just sitting here wondering how I ended up being sucked in this fic-writing business again, considering how I absolutely don't have the skill, as the above-mentioned person has.
Considering also how I was perfectly fine just reading non-Silm fic on AO3 and looking at M posts on tumblr.
If only I did have the skill, or still the practice at least.
ETA 14/10:
I solved the Ivare problem by having Sayandil B, who is p e r f e c t considering his relationship to Feanor (of a bff/quasi-older-brother)
I also considered having Elthedir N but that would squander the 'replacement' drama. I thought of having a Sinda smith OC that goes to replace Ilmarwe* when Ilmarwe dies, but that would me one more character to juggle. *sigh*
It's not like I've even fleshed out my Green Elven OCs either...
For now I have:
- Sayandil, Hithfaer, Morlinn, Glaeril, Elthedir, Emmelin, Gilrinel and Romelinde in their usual roles.
All of them are deployed except Sayandil, and I'm not sure if Emmelin is treating the wounded out on the battlefield or at home; probably on the field.
- I don't remember if I ever mentioned Ilmarwe in any of my fics, I don't thinks so?
I'm thinking of maybe having Oliele Cll as the dead smithing bff from the good old days in the Halls of Aule. But idk, no name really "clicks".
- I considered the OC based on Lord Duvernay that I discussed once but I don't vibe with him at all rn.
- Hrassenel and Gilthalont are the two main brand new 3/4 Green Elven ladies (it's so fucking hard coming up with names with the like 15 Nandorin words that exist)
- Midhir, Nurwe-Luchanar...idk, I feel like they would be too many... or I can turn Midhir into new-name-N? Mmmh. I think I've only ever mentioned him in one fic.
- I mentioned Hithwion once as the guy who saves Estelinde, but I haven't really fleshed him out